Yet Another Company Loses Insurance-Related Lawsuit: Goodwill Industries vs. Philadelphia Indemnity Insurance

As the unceasing pandemic is wreaking havoc all over the world, affecting all types of industries, from auto to healthcare, many companies are trying to mitigate their losses by filing insurance claims. But most of them fail, and Goodwill Industries of Central Oklahoma wasn’t destined to become an exception.

On December 21, the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit has approved that Goodwill’s insurance policy doesn’t apply to the damage dealt by the COVID-19 after every federal appeals court and the vast majority of federal trial courts approved just the same.

The preface of the story is that, in March 2020, Goodwill Industries of Central Oklahoma closed its doors until further notice to comply with both local and state shutdown orders, which in turn resulted in a substantial financial loss. Goodwill mistakenly thought that their coverage would compensate for the losses, even though the policy:

  1. Stated that the insurer would only pay for the suspension of operation due to direct physical loss of or damage to the covered property (although the exact term of “direct physical loss” wasn’t specified).
  2. Contained the exclusion as to losses caused by a virus.

Although COVID-19 did lead to the temporary closure of the physical operation of the company, it hadn’t forced Goodwill to rebuild or repair its premises before they resumed operations, which only reinforced the verdict of the Tenth Circuit.


Oleksandr Rohovnin is a Content Marketer at and an expert contributor to American REIA. His passion is digital marketing, innovative technologies, tech industries, and – above all – distilling vast amounts of complex information into engrossing narratives anyone can relate to. At American REIA, Oleksandr stokes passion for auto insurance and the automotive industry in general in every story he curates.


American REIA